The US & Israel vs Iran: Can Destruction Be Righteous?

There are many voices calling for peace, for the bombing to stop, and surely we can all agree that peace is infinitely better than war. We all want to see an end to the death and destruction. The question is, how do you get peace? If Israel just stopped fighting, would there be peace? Or more destruction? Was Israel wrong to preemptively strike Iran? Should the US have stayed out of it? How can military action which causes death and destruction ever be right?

We see God Himself bringing destruction sometimes, and He’s never wrong. Consider the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, for example, or even the whole world in the time of Noah. God brought destruction upon Israel and even His own temple when things got really dire, and the Bible describes the wrath of God bringing great destruction at the final Day of the Lord. Sometimes destruction is warranted, and the only way to stop evil and bring peace.

Sometimes you have to fight for peace

It’s easy for people who are not in a war zone declare themselves to be simply “anti-war”, but as Emily Schrader points out, this stance insinuates that the alternative is to be “pro-war”, which is obviously a false dichotomy. This foolishly imagines if Israel stopped fighting that their enemies would stop too. In the case of Iran, the Islamic regime has been promising for more than 20 years to wipe Israel off the map, and regularly chant “Death to Israel! Death to America!” They mean it. There’s solid evidence that they were well on their way to carrying out their threats with no intention of stopping.

Iran has declared Israel is a “one bomb country” and they’re right: One nuclear bomb would wipe Israel off the map. It would also wipe the Palestinians off the map at the same time.

The potential loss of life in such an event would be far greater than destroying the regime’s ability to carry it out. However, blocking the genocidal ambitions of the Ayatollahs is difficult, dangerous, and takes a lot of courage. Dealing with evil is always costly, and those who are on the front lines sometimes have to see and do some horrible things so everyone else can sleep in peace. Evil regimes don’t respond to rational negotiations, and to assume that they will is naïve. Of course we’d all prefer peace, but people like Hitler, the Ayatollahs, and others who have called for the destruction of Israel generally don’t agree to “just stop”. They have to be stopped. With force. It’s an unpleasant reality of this world that must be faced.

Unfortunately, evil exists

One of the ideas that helps forge the bizarre alliance between the radical left with militant Islam is the refusal to accept that the goals of the Islamic regime are truly evil. For jihadists wiping every Jew out of existence is a laudable goal, whereas leftists seem to be reluctant to admit that evil exists at all. But Iran’s cruel leaders aren’t misunderstood victims responding to oppression, they’re driven by a genocidal apocalyptic worldview that necessitates the death of every Jew on earth. Moreover, they have been brutally butchering and oppressing their own people for over 40 years. The evil is real, and dealing with it is not for the faint-hearted.

“Appeasement emboldens those who are truly evil,” Emily Schrader argues.It’s not an honorable position, it’s cowardice. And furthermore, it’s ignorant and naïve when faced with actual evil.”

“Evil regimes aren’t disarmed by TED talks,” says Schrader. “They’re stopped when people are willing to pay the price for freedom… Sometimes someone has to do the hard thing.”

“When unchecked and with unlimited power evil people will do evil things… a price must be paid for the protection of human rights and the restoration of liberty, especially in the case of Iran,” she says, and imagining otherwise is “a fantastical emotionally rooted notion with zero basis in reality that ignores human nature and the fact that in this world there are bad people who cannot be reasoned with, and the use of force is sometimes necessary.”

“Acknowledging reality doesn’t make one a warmonger, it makes you an adult, and standing up to evil doesn’t mean you like war. It means that you value peace enough to fight for it,” Emily rightly says, asking, “Are you honestly under the impression that Israelis want war?”

Of course not.

What is actually happening in Iran?

Israel has been aware of the nuclear program in Iran for a long time, and also painfully aware that as the number one sponsor of terrorism in the world, Iran was directly behind the October 7 massacre at the hands of Hamas, an Iranian proxy, as well as all the attacks from Hezbollah and the Houthis in Yemen. When Israel struck Iran it wasn’t really hitting first — the strike came in the middle of a long conflict on multiple fronts with Iran at the head. Moreover, you can see from the charts below that Israel has been specifically striking military targets to prevent further attacks, where as Iran has been deliberately hitting civilians, over and over again. This is in line with their stated aims, calling for the death of all of Israel.

The destruction caused by Iran

God loves life, not death

Israel would far rather live in peace with everyone, but having come through the Holocaust, the Jewish people take genocidal threats seriously. There’s no way Israel will let it happen again.

Iran calls for death to Israel, but Israel doesn’t call for death to Iran in response — we simply say “Am Israel Chai!” The people of Israel live! This is our declaration and our determined response. It’s a cry for life, not death.

Sometimes destruction can preserve life, and is, in the end, the right thing to do. Eliminating a terrorist on the rampage or destroying weapons are two examples of destruction which leads to peace. Israel’s actions, and those of the US, are carefully calculated to prevent mass murder and preserve life as much as possible. The end goal is peace. Far more innocent people would die if the Iranian regime were left to carry out their diabolical schemes.

When you look at the map you can see the comparative size of our countries: Israel has a tenth of the population and a tiny fraction of the real estate. The whole of Israel, together with the West Bank and Gaza, would be under threat together if a nuclear weapon were used to “wipe out the Jews”. Israel’s action to prevent a nuclear threat is protecting all the people in the area who would meet the same fate. Israel has nothing to gain by attacking Iran except the ability to defend civilians from the nuclear threat.

Many are drawing parallels with the time when Western powers tried to appease Hitler, and what a mistake that was.

“We know how that ended,” wrote Sarah Tuttle-Singer. “And maybe that’s why, here in Israel, we don’t have the luxury of illusion anymore. We know what happens when evil is left to metastasize… We’ve seen it — written in ash and blood.” The Holocaust is a lesson that the Jewish people will never forget.

She assures the world, “We’re not seeking war. God knows we want peace. But peace isn’t a slogan. Peace isn’t denial. Peace isn’t closing your eyes while missiles are built underground and uranium spins in centrifuges. Peace comes after safety. After deterrence. After strength. Peace comes when evil knows it will not win.”

The day after… what righteous destruction can bring

What we are all hoping for is a future in which Israelis and Iranians can be friends and not enemies. The majority of Iranians love Israel and vice versa — the regime in no way represents the Iranian people themselves. We are all looking forward to the day when the only things flying back and forth between Israel and Iran are passenger jets, full of Israeli and Iranian tourists, coming to meet their new friends in the neighborhood.

For everything there is a season, and a time for every matter under heaven:

a time to be born, and a time to die;
a time to plant, and a time to pluck up what is planted;
a time to kill, and a time to heal;
a time to break down, and a time to build up;
a time to weep, and a time to laugh;
a time to mourn, and a time to dance;
a time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together;
a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;
a time to seek, and a time to lose;
a time to keep, and a time to cast away;
a time to tear, and a time to sew;
a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;
a time to love, and a time to hate;
a time for war, and a time for peace.

(Ecclesiastes 3:1-8)

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Joshua Aaron (@realjoshuaaaron)

Show the world you are One for Israel!

Pray for Israel

Get your free 31-day prayer guide today!